Home  


  Main Index MAIN
INDEX
Search Posts SEARCH
POSTS
Who's Online WHO'S
ONLINE
Log in LOG
IN

Home: KOI Talk: Koi Breeding:
Should I buy Tosai?

 






 


pisces222
Koi Lover

Nov 23, 2003, 1:39 AM

Post #1 of 4 (951 views)
Shortcut
Should I buy Tosai? Can't Post

Well actually I already did, but I dopn't understand something. It seems the top breeders have this secret art of culling, wait'n'see,... culling,... waiting,... culling... and yet the dominant wisdom is that only a fool buys "show" quality tosai.. caue these fish often change their character drastically throughout their lifecycle... So on what possible basis can one accurately cull their fry, tosai etc... I'm not worried mind you, I'm just stocking my pretty pond, but I really get the impression that the best breeders have trade secrets to influence color, patterns, shape, etc.. so once again,.. whats with the culling.


BranMuffin
Koi Kichi


Nov 23, 2003, 8:55 AM

Post #2 of 4 (944 views)
Shortcut
Re: [pisces222] Should I buy Tosai? [In reply to] Can't Post

Let's start out by saying that under controlled breeding, a female koi can have as many as 250,000 eggs. About 1/4 of that will not get fertilized, that leaves about 187,500 that are and turn into fry's. That's a lot of fry's! Some of these little fry's turns out to be (I believe the term they use is Toby) Tobies which are nothing more than large junk fish, which btw will kill some of the weaker and smaller fish. These gets culled asap and thrown out. About 2-4 weeks later, you can begin to see some patterns on these little guys and lot's of them will be plain colored fish. Through experience, the top breeders will know if these are Ogons or Shiromuji's (plain white fish), and these are generally tossed out except for a very few. But NOT all white fish are junk fish, some of them have the potential of becoming a Kohaku .. it takes a trained eye to spot these and not throw them out.

A couple more weeks and they can determine if the little guys will actually have patterns or turn out pure color: i.e. Black, Brown, which are your Magoi's and Chagois and the majority of them are thrown out.

A few more weeks and the other colors come up such as the Hi and Sumi patterns, and from these patterns they will cull out the ones with real crummy patterns (usually sold to retail outlets (such as K-mart) as pond or ornamental koi). The left overs are the one's that have potential in them to become something more than a Pond or Ornamental fish.

A few more weeks after that then they begin to segregate the one's that have potentials to become "Show Ready Fish" and these are the ones that are placed in Mud Ponds (about 1000 or so). The one's that do not go into the mud ponds are then sold to other Koi dealers in bulk.

The Mud ponds DOESN'T guarantee that all the fish that were put there will come out great looking. As a matter of fact, after some of them dies of uncontrollable diseases, parasites, deterioration and predators, only about 30% of them come out that can be sold for top dollar ...and only 10% of that are potential Champions and Grand Champions which are sold to the Elites for many many thousands of dollars. We're talking $10,000 and above.

There's more to this culling than meets the eye (or that I have outlined here) and it takes years and years of breeding and culling before one can really understand how to cull. I have some idea on how it's done, but even then ... I still wind up with 95% junk! I've been into koi for 25+ years, but just playing around with your Pond fish and tinkering around with breeding will NOT give you the experience to really know your stuff.

Hope this explains some of why breeders cull their fry's. Who wants to end up with a bunch of Big Junk Fish?

You want to buy a fish that's fairly stable. Go with koi that are 2 years or older and 16" and above for Kohakus, Sankes and just about all other fish except Showas, Bekko's and Utsuri's ... then buy the one's that are 3 years old and above and 20" and above. But be ready to spend a few more bucks for these.

Best Regards
Bran

A Koi Pond is never FINISHED, it's always subject to improvement.
Drives the Spouse Crazy!

(This post was edited by BranMuffin on Nov 23, 2003, 9:11 AM)


pisces222
Koi Lover

Nov 23, 2003, 9:25 AM

Post #3 of 4 (937 views)
Shortcut
Re: [BranMuffin] Should I buy Tosai? [In reply to] Can't Post

Thanks so much for the intro/explanation. It sounds like you know more than I'll ever need to know. Well then maybe I can ask one follow up question: Since I care absolutely zero for the show criteria that serious Koi buyers use,.. and rather care only that these fish look beautiful when swimming through three feet of water... is there a kind of koi that are beautiful-yet-underappreciated (so I could better afford their beauty). For example, I understand that competitive koi folks look down their nose at butterfly koi (and don't even consider them koi at all), yet I find these ten-times nmore beautiful than short-finned,.. even grand champions..

Are there other such examples?


BranMuffin
Koi Kichi


Nov 23, 2003, 12:42 PM

Post #4 of 4 (932 views)
Shortcut
Re: [pisces222] Should I buy Tosai? [In reply to] Can't Post

Quote: "I understand that competitive koi folks look down their nose at butterfly koi (and don't even consider them koi at all)"

This is a Japanese thing. Since these didn't originate in Japan, they have a hard time accepting the fact that they can look just as beautiful as the true "Nishikigoi".

I have seen some very beautiful "Butterfly Koi" but I'll admit that I too have been "Brain Washed" (if you will) into thinking that they're not of the same classification (for lack of a better term). There has been a lot of discussions in Japan (top ZNA members) about whether or not to accept these in the shows and no one wants to be the first one to commit themselves. Maybe it's the fear of being embarrased (losing face) should the competition starts beating them at their own game. They are very proud of their "Nishikigoi" and the Koi competition is something they started and have dominated through the years. It would be a major embarrasment if they were to start losing to outsiders. Additionally, Exporting "Nishikigoi" is a Multi-Billion dollar business a year.

Can you imagine what would happen if the outsider who breeds Butterfly Koi start seriously cutting into the Japanese Nishikigoi business? The bottom line here is that if you fear a major competitor, you certainly would not want to promote it. By letting the Butterfly Koi into their competition and it starts winning the major prizes, people would start buying more "Butterfly Koi" and and less "Nishikigoi". (Got the picture?)

Even if by chance someone starts letting the "Butterfly Koi' enter their competition, what do you think the odds are of winning with Japanese Judges around? I really can't blame them. If my pride and my economy is at stake, I would certainly do all possible to try and avoid it. That's just human nature.

These are just theories I have which if you really think about it ... makes a lot of sense. But having said that I would like to point out that "Butterfly Koi" still needs a lot of improvement. For example I have yet to see a good looking Kohaku, Sanke or Showa in a Butterfly koi. They've done a good job on the Ogons and single colored fish, but not in the "Gosankes". Secondly, having seen a lot of "Butterfly koi" .. I'm seeing a lot of deformed fins which in my opionion would be critical on these fish. With their long Pectoral and Tail fins, they can look very elegant ... but at the same token, deformities on these stick out like a sore thumb.

Just my opinions.

Best Regards
Bran

A Koi Pond is never FINISHED, it's always subject to improvement.
Drives the Spouse Crazy!

 
 
 



Search for (options) Back to Koi.com.my Main Page

  Disclaimer  Privacy Statement     
Copyright 2001~ 2002 Hileytech Sdn Bhd , All Rights Reserved.  
No part of the forum postings can be copied without prior permission from Hileytech Sdn Bhd and the Author of the Posting.
For comments and Suggestion, Please contact the Webmaster at koi@hileytech.com